A functional toilet is something that we often take for granted, and they are so important to our daily lives. Unfortunately, there are a variety of issues that can occur and suddenly leave you at a loss for what to do and how to react. 

For many, this naturally leads to the question of ‘is it better to repair or replace a faulty toilet?’ If you find yourself in this situation, we’re here to answer all of the common questions and provide some expert advice to help you out! 

Common Toilet Plumbing Issues

Let’s start by exploring some common toilet plumbing issues that you may encounter or have already encountered to this point. Recognising these problems early can save you time, money, and the headache of an unexpected plumbing emergency.

Leaky Toilet Base: If the toilet base is leaking, water pooling is likely to occur on the floor surrounding it. This issue is usually the result of a faulty wax ring or loose bolts. Regardless of the underlying cause, it’s important to address leaks quickly to prevent any water damage to the bathroom floor.

Clogged Toilet: We’ve all been there—an unexpected clog that seems impossible to clear. Whether it’s caused by excessive toilet paper use, foreign objects or something more stubborn, a clogged toilet is always an annoying disruption to your day. Thankfully, many clogs can be resolved with a plunger or a toilet auger.

Weak Flush: If your toilet struggles to flush completely, you might have a problem with the flush mechanism or even be dealing with a clogged rim. This can be frustrating, as it often requires multiple attempts to get the job done.

Running Toilet: A running toilet is both annoying and costly. This issue typically stems from a malfunctioning flapper valve or a faulty fill valve, which causes water to continuously run into the bowl.

Cracked Tank or Bowl: Cracks in the porcelain of your toilet tank or bowl may lead to leaks and further damage. If you notice water leaking from cracks, ring your nearest PlumbCall team straight away!

Understanding these common issues can help you troubleshoot effectively when problems arise. However, knowing when it’s time to say goodbye to your old toilet is equally important.

Facing a faulty toilet? We provide expert toilet repair in Glen Eden, Hervey Bay, and Kawana to get everything sorted quickly and smoothly

Signs Your Toilet Needs Replacing

Sometimes, it’s clear that a repair just won’t cut it. Here are five signs that indicate it might be time for a replacement:

Frequent Repairs: If you often find yourself repairing your toilet or calling in a professional plumber to fix leaks, clogs, or flushing issues—it might be more cost-effective in the long run to invest in a new model.

Old Age: Depending on the model and maintenance, toilets can last anywhere from 10 to 25 years. So, if your toilet is approaching or surpassing this age range, consider replacing it, especially if it’s showing signs of wear. This is also relevant if you’ve just purchased an older Australian property.

Cracks or Damage: Visible cracks in the toilet tank or bowl are always a red flag. While minor cracks can be repaired sometimes, larger cracks often indicate that the toilet needs to be replaced to prevent leaks and further damage.

Inefficiency: Older toilets, particularly those made before the 1990s, use significantly more water per flush than more efficient modern toilets. 

Unpleasant Odours: If you notice unusual odours that persist even after a deep clean, it might be a sign of further underlying issues. These could be a broken seal or cracks that allow sewage gases to escape. In this circumstance, a replacement may be the best option.

If you’ve noticed any of these signs, it’s worth considering whether a new toilet could save you money and hassle in the long run. At PlumbCall, we provide domestic repairs and maintenance services across Australia. 

Get a Professional Opinion

Much like other plumbing appliances and fixtures, we always recommend getting a professional opinion. At PlumbCall, we have licensed plumbers operating across Australia who can provide sound advice and guidance.

If the toilet’s beyond repair, this doesn’t mean you’ll have to break the bank and purchase the most expensive model available. In fact, there are many affordable options that will tend to suit your needs just fine.

Once on site, our plumbers will assess the state of your current toilet, then offer advice on whether repairs will do the trick or its time to invest in a newer model. We’ll treat your problems seriously and certainly won’t leave you wondering! 

Benefits of Toilet Replacement

Replacing your old toilet can come with numerous benefits that extend beyond simply fixing the existing issues. Here are five advantages to consider:

Water Efficiency: Upgrading to a modern toilet is a great way to reduce your water usage, particularly if it has low-flush modes that are specifically designed to cut down water consumption.

Improved Performance: Newer toilets often come with advanced flushing technologies that provide a more powerful flush. Say goodbye to clogs and hello to efficient waste removal!

Enhanced Comfort: Modern toilets offer improved design features that enhance user comfort. Options such as elongated bowls, higher seat heights, and ergonomic designs can make a big difference in your bathroom experience.

Aesthetic Appeal: A new toilet can provide a fresh look for your bathroom. With various styles, colours, and finishes available, you can choose a toilet that complements your bathroom decor and adds to its overall aesthetic.

Lower Maintenance Costs: New toilets are less likely to develop issues compared to older models. By investing in a replacement, you can minimise ongoing maintenance costs and enjoy peace of mind knowing that you have a reliable fixture.

These benefits make a compelling case for considering toilet replacement, especially if your current model is showing signs of wear and tear.

What’s the Average Cost for a Toilet Replacement in Australia?

According to 2024 data from HiPages, the average cost for toilet replacement in Australia typically ranges between $150 to $600, while a more straightforward job will be somewhere in the range of $150 to $250. The final cost will be influenced by all of the following factors: 

Toilet Unit: Prices for the toilet can and will vary, ranging anywhere from $100 to $800 or more for high-end models. The type of toilet (e.g., one-piece vs. two-piece, wall-mounted vs. floor-mounted) will significantly affect the cost.

Installation Fees: Hiring a plumber for installation can add anywhere from $100 to $300, depending on the complexity of the job and your location.

Additional Costs: Don’t forget to factor in the costs of any additional materials or modifications that may be necessary, such as new plumbing fixtures, wax rings, or floor repairs. These could add another $50 to $150 to the overall expense.

Always get a licensed plumber to handle the job! The last thing you want is another issue to arise right after the new toilet is installed. Of course, prices may vary from those listed above, so be sure to get multiple quotes as well.

A Few Key Things to Consider

Before rushing to make a decision, there are a few key factors to consider when weighing whether to repair or replace your toilet:

Assess the Extent of Damage: Take a close look at your toilet and evaluate the issues at hand. Minor problems may warrant a repair, while significant damage may make replacement a better option.

Consider Your Budget: Think about your financial situation and what you can afford. While repairs may seem cheaper upfront, frequent issues could add up over time, making a replacement more cost-effective.

Evaluate Your Lifestyle: If you’re planning a bathroom renovation or if you anticipate needing more reliable fixtures due to increased household traffic, it might be worth investing in a new toilet that meets your needs.

Think About Efficiency: Upgrading to a water-efficient toilet can save you money on water bills in the long run and reduce your environmental impact.

Seek Out Professional Advice: Consulting a plumbing professional can provide you with valuable insights and recommendations tailored to your specific situation. PlumbCall is here to help you assess your options and make an informed choice.

Ultimately, the decision to repair or replace a toilet boils down to the specific issues at hand, your budget, and your long-term goals for your bathroom. Whether you opt for repairs or replacement, PlumbCall is here to provide you with expert advice and high-quality plumbing solutions. 

Don’t hesitate to reach out to us for assistance— we offer domestic maintenance services across Australia, and your toilet troubles are just a call away from a resolution!